We all know the rule. No religion, no politics, and everybody gets home in one piece.
It’s a lovely rule. Unfortunately, nobody told the table.
Because the holiday stress many of us carry into November and December isn’t really about the topics. It’s about the people. And goodness, we do love our people. Most of the time.
There’s the relative who has a comment about everything we do, and somehow, we always end up seated right next to them. The cousin who will probably have one too many and get a little loud by dessert.
The ex we’ll have to be civil to in a crowded kitchen. Uncle Bob and his “jokes.” Grandma, who loves us dearly but cannot, for the life of her, understand why we don’t do things the way she did.
And underneath all of it, there’s the pressure of hosting, or being a guest in someone else’s very specific way of doing things. Apparently, even the gravy has rules.
I’m including myself here, sweet friend. How many of us have driven to a family gathering rehearsing a conversation in the car, only to spend the entire drive home rehearsing what we should have said? And that second version? Oh, it was brilliant.
So I’m not suggesting we avoid the holidays or the people who come with them. I’d just love for us to walk in with a few decisions already made and a few helpful sentences tucked into our back pockets.
Because sometimes, a little preparation is the best gift we can give our peace of mind.
Keeping the Peace Isn’t the Same as Keeping Quiet
For a long time, I think many of us believed keeping the peace meant swallowing whatever came our way. Smile, nod, change the subject, and go home with a headache. Maybe a little indigestion, too.
But is that really peace? Or have we just handed the remote control to whoever at the table happens to be the loudest?
Keeping our peace is a little different. It means deciding ahead of time what we’re comfortable talking about, what we’d rather leave alone, and how we want to respond when things go sideways anyway.
We can be kind without becoming a doormat. We can be clear without turning into a bulldozer. And yes, both are possible in the same evening. I’ve seen it happen. Occasionally, I’ve even pulled it off myself!
Here’s a question I’d love for us to consider before that first holiday gathering:
When I’m driving home tonight, who do I want to have been at that table?
Notice I didn’t ask who we want to impress, correct, or win an argument with. I’m asking who we want to be.
That little distinction can change quite a lot.
Before You Walk In: The Three-Line Plan
Most of us arrive at holiday gatherings with a full plate before anyone has even served dinner. We’ve got expectations, family history, a few old buttons just waiting to be pushed, and possibly a casserole balanced on our lap.
So let’s make this easy.
Before the gathering, pull out the notes app on your phone and write down three things.
- One topic I’d love to talk about. Think of a genuine question for someone you care about. “How did that trip go?” “How’s the new job treating you?” “What have you been enjoying lately?” A little genuine curiosity can go a long way toward creating a lovely conversation.
- One sentence for changing lanes. Choose something you can say when the conversation starts heading somewhere you’d rather not go. I’ve included some possibilities below. Pick one that sounds like you, and practice saying it out loud. Yes, actually out loud. Your steering wheel won’t judge.
- One graceful exit. Decide what you’ll do if you need a breather. Help with the dishes. Check on the dog. Take a little walk. Offer to refill the drinks. In my experience, nobody has ever tackled a guest for volunteering to clear the plates.
That’s it. Three little lines.
They’ll fit on a sticky note, which, depending on how the afternoon goes, may be roughly the size of our remaining patience by four o’clock.
The Exact Words: What to Say When Things Get Interesting
Sometimes the hardest part of an uncomfortable conversation is simply knowing what to say.
And when we’re caught off guard, we may find ourselves explaining, defending, or offering a ten-minute TED Talk that nobody requested.
So I’ve gathered a few sentences we can borrow. Make them your own. Say them in your natural voice.
The trick is to keep them short, because every extra explanation can become another little doorway into an argument.
___
The One Who Criticizes Everything
“You’re still doing that?”
“I would never let my kids…”
“Are you sure about that haircut?”
Ah, yes. The family member who apparently received a lifetime appointment to the Department of Unsolicited Opinions.
We may love them dearly, but that doesn’t mean we need to defend every choice we’ve ever made.
Sometimes the kindest thing we can do for ourselves, and the conversation, is acknowledge the comment lightly and move along.
A few possibilities:
- “You might be right. Can you pass the potatoes?”
- “I’m happy with it. Thanks for looking out for me, though.”
- “That’s one way to do it. How’s your knee been?”
A little smile helps. No sarcasm, no sharp edges, just a gentle change of direction.
It may feel a bit unsatisfying the first time. After all, we had an excellent comeback prepared! But by the third time, we might discover how lovely it feels to let a comment pass without picking it up and carrying it around all evening.
___
Politics, Religion, and Whatever Else Is Making Headlines
There’s always something, isn’t there?
And while meaningful conversations about important issues certainly have their place, we get to decide whether Thanksgiving dinner is the place we want to have them.
Sometimes we can acknowledge a subject without accepting an invitation to debate it.
Here are a few ways to do that:
- “I love you too much to argue with you over pie.”
- “I’m off duty on that one tonight. Tell me about the kitchen remodel.”
- “We’re probably not going to agree, and I’d really rather enjoy our time together. Deal?”
And if someone keeps pushing?
We can simply repeat ourselves, kindly and calmly.
I know, I know. It feels a little strange to say the same thing twice. But offering a brand-new explanation every time gives someone a brand-new point to argue.
Sometimes repeating a gentle boundary works beautifully. And when it doesn’t, we can always excuse ourselves for a few minutes.
There is absolutely no rule requiring us to solve the world’s problems before the pumpkin pie is served.
___
Grandma and the Guilt
Now, this one deserves a little extra tenderness.
Sometimes the people who love us most have the hardest time understanding why we do things differently.
Maybe we’re changing a family tradition. Maybe we’re celebrating with a different group of people this year. Maybe we’ve decided that twelve side dishes are eleven too many.
To us, it may feel like a perfectly reasonable choice. To Grandma, it might feel like something precious is slipping away.
We can honor that love and those feelings while still making our own decisions.
We might say:
- “I know this matters to you. It matters to me too, just in a different way.”
- “I love that you care this much. We’re doing it our way this year, and I’d really love for you to be part of it.”
- “I’m not going to change my mind, Grandma, but I love you just as much as ever.”
Sometimes a gentle touch on the arm, a warm smile, or a little reassurance can help.
We don’t have to choose between loving someone and honoring our own decisions. There can be room for both.
And who knows? Grandma might even discover she likes the new tradition. Although I wouldn’t necessarily lead with that prediction.
___
Uncle Bob and the Comment That Crosses a Line
We’ve all encountered moments when a conversation moves beyond awkward and into something genuinely hurtful.
Maybe someone makes a racist remark, says something cruel, or takes a shot at someone who isn’t in a position to speak up for themselves.
This is where keeping the peace may mean speaking up.
We can be respectful without pretending something is okay when it isn’t.
And we don’t necessarily need a speech. Sometimes one direct sentence is enough.
- “That’s not okay with me.”
- “We don’t talk that way at this table.”
- “I’m going to ask you to stop.”
Then, if possible, let the statement stand.
We don’t have to turn the moment into a debate or attempt to change someone’s entire worldview before dessert.
If the conversation escalates, we can step away. If someone is being targeted, we can also check in with them and offer support.
The important thing is that we have choices. We can speak with conviction and still decide how much of our energy we’re willing to give the situation.
And Uncle Bob? Well, perhaps this year he’ll discover that not every thought needs a microphone.
___
The Guest Who Drinks Too Much
This one can be especially difficult, particularly when it’s someone we care about and we’ve seen the pattern before.
Maybe the evening starts pleasantly enough, but as the drinks keep coming, so do the louder stories, the arguments, or the uncomfortable moments.
When we know this may happen, a little planning beforehand can help.
If we’re hosting, we can think through what we’ll serve, how alcohol will be handled, and how everyone will get home safely. If we’re attending, we can talk privately with the host ahead of time or decide when we’d like to leave.
And once someone has had too much to drink, trying to reason with them may not be especially productive.
A conversation that sounds perfectly logical at eight o’clock in the evening can look quite different at eight o’clock the next morning.
Depending on the situation, we might say:
- “Let’s get some air.”
- “I’m going to sit with the kids for a bit.”
- Quietly to the host: “Would you like a hand with this, or would you rather I stay out of it?”
Of course, if someone is becoming aggressive or unsafe, protecting ourselves and others takes priority. And we don’t let someone who’s impaired get behind the wheel.
There’s also something I think many of us need to hear, especially when we love someone who struggles with alcohol.
We can care deeply about someone without taking responsibility for fixing everything in that moment.
A long-standing problem isn’t likely to be resolved at a holiday dinner table.
We can offer compassion, encourage appropriate help, and still give ourselves permission to step away.
___
The Ex
Oh, the holidays do have a way of bringing together people who might otherwise prefer a little more distance.
Shared children, shared friends, overlapping family traditions. Suddenly, there we are, reaching for the same serving spoon in the same crowded kitchen.
The good news? We don’t have to figure out the entire relationship over the mashed potatoes.
Sometimes a perfectly lovely goal is simply to be gracious, brief, and busy.
We can even decide on a few sentences ahead of time:
- “Hi. Good to see you.”
- “The kids look happy.”
- “I’m going to go help in the kitchen.”
And that’s enough.
Nothing to prove. Nothing to process. No need to revisit the last twelve years because someone asked us to pass the rolls.
We can be cordial without inviting a conversation we’re not ready to have.
Some things are better discussed another day, in another setting. And some conversations may not need to happen at all.
A Little Holiday Wisdom for Hosts and Guests
___
If You’re Hosting
Can we talk about the pressure we put on ourselves?
Somewhere along the way, many of us decided a successful holiday gathering requires a perfectly decorated house, a magnificent meal, cheerful guests, and a kitchen that somehow cleans itself.
And let’s not forget the centerpiece that looks like it belongs in a magazine.
But I wonder how often the people coming to our homes are actually expecting all of that.
Sometimes the standards we’re trying so hard to meet are ones we’ve created ourselves.
What if we gave ourselves permission to make things a little easier?
We could even say it out loud:
- “Dinner’s around three-ish. We’re using paper plates, and I’m delighted about it.”
- “I’m making the turkey and the pie. If anyone feels strongly about having a particular side dish, congratulations! You’ve found your contribution.”
- “I’m taking ten minutes to sit down before dessert. Nobody panic. I’ll be back.”
A relaxed host can make a gathering feel more welcoming. And when we allow ourselves a little breathing room, we may actually get to enjoy the people we invited.
Imagine that!
___
If You’re the Guest
Being a guest comes with its own little dance.
We’re in someone else’s home, following someone else’s traditions, and possibly navigating a very specific set of instructions about the gravy boat.
One of the nicest things we can do is offer help in a way that makes it easy for the host to say yes.
Instead of the usual “Let me know if you need anything,” we might try:
- “What can I actually take off your plate? Dishes, drinks, or keeping your mother-in-law company?”
- “I’ve got the kids’ table. You go enjoy yourself.”
- And when it’s time to leave: “This has been lovely. We’re going to head out while it’s still lovely.”
That last one may be my favorite.
Sometimes knowing when to make a graceful exit is a wonderful little life skill.
When It Goes Sideways Anyway
Now, even with our three-line plan, our best intentions, and a generous helping of holiday spirit, things may still get a little messy.
Someone says the thing.
Or, heaven help us, we say the thing.
We’re human. It happens.
And when it does, we don’t have to decide that the entire evening is ruined.
Here’s a little reset we can try. It takes about ninety seconds, give or take a few depending on how far away the bathroom is.
- Step away for a moment. The bathroom, the porch, or a quick trip to the car to “grab something” can give us a little space.
- Give ourselves a moment to settle. A few slow breaths, some cool water on our wrists, or simply standing quietly can help us collect our thoughts.
- Ask one question: “What do I want to be true when I drive home tonight?”
- Choose the next kind thing. Maybe we pour someone a cup of coffee, ask a thoughtful question, or help clear the table. And if something needs an apology or a little repair, we can begin there.
We don’t have to fix the entire evening in one heroic effort.
Sometimes we only need to decide what we’d like to do with the next ninety seconds.
And if the kindest next step is to leave, that’s a choice too.
Peace Is Not the Absence of Uncle Bob
Here’s what I’ve come to believe.
We can’t control who shows up at the holiday table, what they say, what they drink, or what year they seem to think they’re living in.
We can, however, make some decisions about who we want to be, how we want to respond, and what we’re willing to participate in.
And I think there’s something wonderfully freeing about that.
We don’t have to wait for everyone else to behave perfectly before we can experience a little peace of our own.
We can love our families, appreciate the traditions that bring us together, laugh at the inevitable holiday chaos, and still honor the person we’re becoming.
One of the truths I hold close is this:
The Power breathing you is greater than any circumstance, situation, or condition.
I believe that with my whole heart.
And yes, sweet friend, I believe it applies just as much at the kids’ table, in the kitchen, and across from Uncle Bob as it does in the quieter moments of our lives.
So here’s my invitation for this week.
Before your next gathering, write down those three little lines. One conversation you’d love to have. One sentence to help you change direction. One graceful exit if you need a break.
Put them in your phone. Read them in the car. Maybe even practice saying them out loud.
And while you’re at it, give yourself permission to enjoy the good moments, even if the whole day isn’t perfect.
Because the holidays don’t have to go exactly as planned for us to find something wonderful in them.
And if all of this is bringing up something a little deeper, perhaps you’ve noticed that you’re spending a lot of energy keeping everyone else comfortable while quietly setting your own needs aside, I’d love to talk with you.
Sometimes our holiday experiences shine a light on patterns we’ve been living with all year.
I offer a free Discovery Session where we can have an honest conversation about what’s happening in your life, what you’d really love, and what one small step toward that vision might look like.
No pressure. No pitch. No homework. Just a chance to talk about you and the life you’d love to be living by this time next year.
And in the meantime, may your holidays be filled with love, laughter, meaningful connections, and just enough patience to make it through Uncle Bob’s second helping of pie.
With love,
Rosemary Gibson